Footballer's Injury Claim Denied by AFCA Due to Policy Limitations

2

The incident arose after the player suffered an injury to her left ankle, prompting an investigation that revealed an "anomalous bony structure" in her right ankle, necessitating surgery. She subsequently filed a claim for the recovery expenses under a group personal accident and illness policy arranged by Football NSW.

AIG Australia contended that the claim could not be fulfilled as the condition did not satisfy their policy's injury definition. According to the insurer, an injury had to result from "violent, external and visible means" and "occur independently from any other cause." The player's GP described the condition as a bony deformity resulting from repetitive stress related to playing football, rather than a fracture.

The player argued that the rigorous nature of playing football constituted "violent, external and visible means" and that the injury was both unforeseen and accidental. However, the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) clarified that the policy necessitated a single, standalone event influenced by a "strong visible force, external to the insured person."

In its official ruling, AFCA concluded that the repetitive strain stemming from the football activities, developing gradually over time, did not align with the policy's injury criteria. The ruling highlighted that the condition was not a consequence of a single, isolated event nor was it caused by an external force.

The ombudsman further noted, "Given the nature of the condition, the claim could not be established within the policy's injury requirements, thereby nullifying any claimable loss by the complainant."

The resolution from AFCA underscores the importance of policyholders understanding the specific terms and definitions embedded within insurance policies to determine coverage eligibility effectively.

Published:Friday, 30th May 2025
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Clear

Record Highs in UK Pet Insurance Payouts Reflect Rising Vet Costs 03 Jun 2025: Paige Estritori The landscape of pet insurance in the UK has marked another milestone, with payouts reaching an unprecedented £1.23 billion ($2.36 billion) last year. This 4% increase over the previous year is attributed to soaring veterinary fees, reflecting broader inflation trends in the industry. - read more

Flood Crisis Exposes Insurance Shortfalls in NSW: Brokers Warn of Unmet Coverage Needs 03 Jun 2025: Paige Estritori As floods wreak havoc across New South Wales, the stark reality of inadequate insurance coverage emerges as a pressing issue for farmers, homeowners, and businesses. In localities like Taree, the lack of flood coverage is a cause for concern as the region grapples with the aftermath of record-breaking rains and destruction. - read more

Footballer's Injury Claim Denied by AFCA Due to Policy Limitations 30 May 2025: Paige Estritori A female football player has faced disappointment after her claim for physiotherapy expenses was denied by her insurer, AIG Australia. The athlete's claim was linked to a disorder in her right ankle, identified as osteochondritis dissecans after doctors conducted an X-ray. - read more

NSW Premier Urges Speedy Action on Flood Claims as Industry Expands Support 30 May 2025: Paige Estritori The New South Wales Premier, Chris Minns, is urging insurance companies to expedite the processing of flood claims as the number of affected policyholders grows. In response to the ongoing natural disaster, the insurance industry has opened a second hub to provide assistance. - read more

Insurer Ordered to Refund GAP Premium After Unfair Sale 28 May 2025: Paige Estritori A significant decision has been made as an insurer, Eric Insurance, is required to refund a consumer for a Guaranteed Asset Protection (GAP) policy deemed unfairly sold 13 years ago. The policy stemmed from a $31,000 vehicle loan, and the consumer argued that misleading practices influenced this purchase. - read more